Feud over the future of America’s power grid

Some scientists are engaged in “an increasingly bitter and personal feud” over how much power the United States can get from renewables.


A recently published article by the Washington Post explains how scientists are engaged in an increasingly bitter and personal feud over how much power the United States can get from renewable sources.

A large group of these researchers are taking aim at a popular publication that claimed the country could move beyond fossil fuels entirely by 2055, as being “contentious”.



Now a new paper argues that they “used invalid modeling tools, contained modeling errors, and made implausible and inadequately supported assumptions.”

“We thought we had to write a peer reviewed piece to highlight some of the mistakes and have a broader discussion about what we really need to fight climate change,” said lead study author Christopher Clack of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Earth System Research Laboratory.

“And we felt the only way to do it in a fair and unbiased way was to go through peer review and have external referees vet it to make sure we’re not saying anything that’s untrue in our piece.”

“The debate is crucial”, writes Chris Mooney of the Washington Post, “while it’s great to talk about wind and solar in theory, the reality is that the electrons that they generate have to be sent through wires and transmission stations to satisfy needs at particular places and at particular times…which remains a mostly unsolved problem right now”.

Vice also covers what it describes as “one of the most vitriolic fights in science publishing”, and MIT technology review also covers the story.

More Stories From Around the Web:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What to Read Next:

Canada needs to boost its solar potential

Last year confirmed what many within the renewable energy sector have known: Renewable energy, specifically solar, is growing at an...

Game-changer breakthrough for organic solar cells

In an advance that could push cheap, ubiquitous solar power closer to reality, University of Michigan researchers have found a...

Is a diverse workforce the way forward for solar?

The Solar Foundation’s 2017 U.S. Solar Industry Diversity Study was released last month, causing a stir among solar workers and...

DOE discovery could lead to better batteries

A collaboration led by scientists at the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Brookhaven National Laboratory has observed an unexpected phenomenon...

How do extreme weather conditions affect solar efficiency?

North America is experiencing one of its coldest spells in recent years, with temperatures dropping to -20F(-29C). And the temperatures...